Pop Idol Anime sugarcoat the harsh reality of the industry: Is the exploitation being sensitized?

Pop Idol Anime sugarcoat the harsh reality of the industry: Is the exploitation being sensitized?

Pop idol anime, a beloved subgenre of the anime world, is centered around the lives of idol singers and groups. These shows typically revolve around a group of young girls/ boys striving to become idols, showcasing the hurdles and sacrifices they encounter on their journey. Idol anime has found a dedicated fanbase, particularly among young girls and women, offering them an escape into a world of dreams and aspirations.

Tracing the history of Idol anime

A still from Magical Angel Creamy Mami
A still from Magical Angel Creamy Mami (Image via IMDb)

The roots of idol anime trace back to 1983 when the groundbreaking series Magical Angel Creamy Mami made its debut. With its heartwarming tale of a young girl transformed into an idol by magical aliens, Creamy Mami captured the hearts of viewers everywhere and set the stage for the genre to flourish.

Since the inception of Magical Angel Creamy Mami, the world of anime has witnessed an influx of popular idol-centered series such as Love Live!, Aikatsu!, and The Idolm@ster. Notably, idol anime has transcended cultural boundaries, with many series being dubbed or subtitled in various languages for international audiences.

Common themes in Idol anime

A still from Idolmaster
A still from Idolmaster (Image via IMDb)

Idol anime consistently incorporates several recurring themes:

  • The importance of hard work and dedication: These series emphasize the rigorous training and dedication required to ascend the ladder of idol stardom. Protagonists often undergo years of training before making their debut as idols.
  • The power of friendship: Strong bonds of friendship are a staple in idol anime, with these relationships serving as pillars of support. These friendships enable the idol characters to overcome obstacles and pursue their dreams with unwavering determination.
  • The pursuit of dreams: Idol anime fervently encourages viewers to chase their dreams, no matter how daunting they may appear. Characters in these shows confront numerous hurdles on their path to success but never lose sight of their aspirations.

The stark reality of the idol industry

A still from idolish7 anime
A still from idolish7 anime (Image via IMDb)

In stark contrast to the idealized world of idol anime, the real-life idol industry in Japan is marked by cutthroat competition and demanding standards. Aspiring idols often toil through years of grueling training before even considering their debut, all while navigating strict rules and regulations.

Idols endure immense pressure to maintain an immaculate image, often facing expectations to be slender and attractive. Personal relationships are discouraged, and online harassment and abuse can become a harrowing part of their lives.

How idol anime softens the harsh edges

A still from Wake Up, Girls!
A still from Wake Up, Girls! (Image via IMDb)

Idol anime has a tendency to sugarcoat the harsh realities of the idol industry. These series typically portray idol life as glamorous and exciting, downplaying the arduous challenges and sacrifices that idols endure.

In these animated worlds, idols train in luxurious facilities and savor sumptuous meals. However, the reality is often much bleaker, with many idols training in cramped and outdated spaces, adhering to stringent diets to maintain their desired figures. Idol anime also often idealizes the industry despite its exploitative aspects, showcasing successful and happy idol characters even in the face of demanding rules and regulations.

Is exploitation being brought to light?

A still from idolish7 anime
A still from idolish7 anime (Image via IMDb)

In recent years, there has been a noticeable shift towards more realistic portrayals of the idol industry within idol anime. Some series have taken steps to address the exploitative aspects, shedding light on the long hours of training, strict dietary restrictions, and the lack of personal lives and privacy.

For instance, the series Wake Up, Girls! chronicles the struggles of a group of idols striving for stardom. It authentically depicts their training in cramped facilities, adherence to strict diets, and the relentless pressure to maintain an ideal image. Similarly, idolish7, which follows the lives of male idols, delves into the industry’s challenges, including grueling training, image management, and the emotional and psychological toll of idol life.

Recent trends in pop idol anime

A still from Oshi no Ko anime
A still from Oshi no Ko anime (Image via IMDb)

While there is still room for improvement in terms of accurately portraying the idol industry, the shift towards realism is a promising sign. It reflects an industry that is increasingly conscious of its exploitative practices and willing to address them, ultimately leading to more informed and empathetic viewers.

One recent standout, Oshi no Ko, takes a unique approach by exploring deeper into the dark side of the idol industry. This series offers viewers a more unfiltered glimpse into the challenges and exploitative aspects faced by idols, making it a notable exception to the sugarcoating trend.

Conclusion

In conclusion, idol anime does indeed tend to sugarcoat the harsh realities of the idol industry. However, it sparks a nuanced debate about whether it sensitizes or sensationalizes the industry. While these shows offer an escape into a world of dreams and aspirations, they also carry a responsibility to acknowledge and shed light on the genuine challenges faced by idols. The recent trend towards more realistic portrayals indicates a positive step towards creating a more balanced and empathetic perspective of the idol industry.

To receive more updates about anime and manga subscribe to  Spielanime Newsletter!

Scroll to Top