Top 5 Controversial Anime Characters who divided fanbases.

Top 5 Controversial Anime Characters who divided fanbases.

Certain anime characters elicit strong reactions from fans, garnering both ardent love and hatred due to their questionable morals, irritating personalities, or highly controversial actions that never fail to spark intense and endless debate within the anime community. Here are 5 of the Top 5 Controversial Anime Characters who divided fanbases into fiercely opposed camps.

Top 5 Controversial Anime Characters who divided fanbases.

5. Shinji Ikari (Neon Genesis Evangelion)

The insecure protagonist of the mecha anime Evangelion, Shinji draws intense ire from many fans for constantly whining, refusing to pilot the Eva mech, and his frequent breakdowns.

However, Shinji also has a legion of diehard supporters who deeply relate to his profound struggles with crippling anxiety, depression, and the enormous pressure placed on him. Shinji’s glaring flaws yet understandable psychology make him one of animeโ€™s most polarising and hotly debated characters.

4. Askeladd (Vinland Saga)

What will Vinland Saga Season 3 be about
Askeladd in Vinland Saga. (Image courtesy Wit Studio)

Askeladd is a cunning Viking widely hated by some fans for his questionable methods and lack of honor. However, Askeladd’s diehard followers argue he’s a far more nuanced antihero fighting to create a world without war and hypocrisy.

While some people hate him for turning Thorfinn into what he is today, others appreciate how vital his character is to his character development and the overall narrative. His highly questionable actions taken to fulfill this dream make Askeladd an incredibly divisive character.

3. Eren Yeager (Attack on Titan)

Eren attracts criticism for his hotheaded ruthlessness and tendency to endanger allies in his fight against the Titans. But his defenders view him as a complex product of trauma pursuing freedom by any means necessary. His extremist philosophy and contradictory humanity have ignited endless fiery debate within the fandom.

2. Light Yagami (Death Note)

Light Yagami from Season 1 Episode 1 of Death Note
Light Yagami from Season 1 Episode 1 of Death Note (Image via Madhouse Studio)

Light is despised by some for his swift descent into megalomania and cruelty after getting the Death Note. However, his initial mission to punish criminals also earns him ample support. Light’s profoundly contradictory personality, where noble ends seem to mask his underlying tyrannical hunger for power, cements him as one of animeโ€™s most contentious figures.

1. Sasuke Uchiha (Naruto)

A character who provokes endless discussion, many criticize Sasuke for betraying his village and friends in his ruthless quest for revenge against Itachi. But others admire his tragic past, complicated bonds with Team 7, and ultimate redemption.

His morally ambiguous motivations fueled by hatred and the fallacies around him alongside his aloof demeanor have fiercely divided the Naruto fanbase. His convoluted nature, complex character, and developmental arc are more akin to a seinen character stuck in a shounen world, which not all fans prefer.


These characters have ignited endless fiery debates within the anime community regarding morality, motivation, and redemption. Their highly controversial beliefs and actions force audiences to engage in reflection. They prove anime’s unique power to craft remarkably complex figures who defy all simplistic interpretations, keeping their divisive legacies sparking impassioned discussion for years to come.

For more such lists, stay with Spiel Anime.

Scroll to Top