One Piece Live Action vs. Anime: Which one wins?

One Piece Live Action vs. Anime: Which one wins?

After years in the making, the live-action adaptation of One Piece was finally released on Netflix on August 31st, 2023. The show has been met with mostly positive reviews, with many fans praising it for staying true to the source material and the impressive special effects.

This is a major accomplishment, as live-action adaptations of anime and manga are often met with skepticism, as they rarely live up to the expectations of fans. However, One Piece seems to have bucked the trend and has blown people’s minds with its faithfulness and excitement.

One Piece Live Action vs. Anime: Which one wins?
One Piece | Image via Netflix

The Idea of One Piece

One Piece is a Japanese manga series written and illustrated by Eiichiro Oda. It has been serialized in Shueisha’s Shonen manga magazine Weekly Shonen Jump since July 1997, with its individual chapters compiled into 106 tankobon volumes as of July 2023.

The idea of One Piece is simple: a young man, Monkey D. Luffy, who gains the power to stretch his body like rubber after unintentionally eating a Devil Fruit sets out on a journey from the East Blue Sea to find the titular One Piece, a treasure left behind by the former Pirate King, Gol D. Roger.

One Piece Live Action vs. Anime: Which one wins?
One Piece | Image courtesy of Toei Animation

Along the way, he gathers a crew of pirates, including Roronoa Zoro, Nami, Usopp, Sanji, Tony Tony Chopper, Nico Robin, Franky, and Brook. The Straw Hat Pirates travel the Grand Line, a series of treacherous islands, in search of the One Piece. Along the way, they face many challenges, including powerful pirates, the World Government, and the mysterious forces of the Void Century.

However, the story is much more complex than that. One Piece is a story about friendship, adventure, and the power of dreams. It is a story about overcoming challenges and never giving up on your goals.

How did the live adaptation fare in comparison?

Netflix’s One Piece is a major success. It is a faithful adaptation of the manga that is also entertaining and exciting for a live-action audience.

One Piece Live Action vs. Anime: Which one wins?
One Piece | Image via Netflix

There are a few reasons why Netflix’s One Piece has been so successful.

  1. The show is produced by Tomorrow Studios and Netflix, two companies with a proven track record of producing high-quality live-action adaptations.
  2. The show is written by Matt Owens and Steven Maeda, two writers who are fans of the original manga and anime.
  3. The show stars a talented cast of actors, including Iñaki Godoy as Monkey D. Luffy, Mackenyu as Roronoa Zoro, Emily Rudd as Nami, Jacob Romero Gibson as Usopp, and Taz Skylar as Sanji.
One Piece Live Action vs. Anime: Which one wins?
One Piece | Image via Netflix

Netflix’s One Piece is a faithful adaptation of the early chapters of the manga. The show captures the spirit of the original story, while also making some changes to make it more accessible to a live-action audience. For example, the show has been condensed to eight episodes, and some of the more fantastical elements of the manga have been toned down. However, the show still retains the humor, adventure, and excitement of the original story.

One Piece Live Action vs. Anime: Which one wins?

The adaptation was the brainchild of Marty Adelstein, the CEO of Tomorrow Studios and Oda. They both made sure that the adaptation paid its due respect to its longstanding anime counterpart and left no stone unturned to ensure the correct direction and execution of the filming process.

According to Emma Sullivan, one of the directors of the show, Oda had the final say on everything, from the script to the visual effects. He did not hesitate to request reshoots and changes if something did not meet his standards.

“You want them [fans] to be happy, you know, but I think the only way we can do that is to make [Eiichiro] Oda happy. When he saw stuff that he didn’t like, we redid it,” Sullivan said.

While they are sides of the same coin, the anime version is definitely more famous and welcomed by audiences. The anime has been running for over 20 years and has a massive following. It is known for its authenticity, heartwarming scenes, hilarious anecdotes, and loyal fanbase. Toppling over a legacy like that is next to impossible.

One Piece Live Action vs. Anime: Which one wins?
One Piece | Image via Netflix

In conclusion, the show has broken the curse of live-action anime adaptations, and it is a sign that more and more anime and manga will be adapted for live-action in the future. But the anime will definitely reign over the hearts of the fans for the years to come.

Scroll to Top