After 5 years of long wait, the announcement that JC Staff Studio would return to animate One-Punch Man season 3 landed with a mixed punch. Given that season 2 had left many fans disappointed because the studio couldn’t keep up with the artistic details in the manga, now the question remains: will they be able to pull off something magical if given enough time or was it better if the MAPPA fans’ hopes of taking on the project were a preferable choice for One Punch Man Season 3? While some fans cautiously embraced their return, others longed for the rumoured involvement of powerhouse studio MAPPA. Let’s peel back the layers of this animation debate.
How do the fans feel about the return of JC Staff Studio for One Punch Man season 3?
Many fans felt let down by Season 2, which was also animated by J.C. Staff. It fell short of the visual spectacle fans craved for the series’ action-heavy narrative, with inconsistent animation quality compared to the excellent Season 1. This sparked calls for a different studio to take over, with MAPPA being the favoured choice.
Yet, some fans remained hopeful. According to them, JC Staff returning as One Punch Man Season 3 Animation Studio may not be a bad thing despite season 2’s failure, the studio’s familiarity with the source material and the chance to fix past flaws gave them a bit of optimism.
- Currently Airing Shows:Â J.C. Staff is actively involved in the production of several ongoing anime series in 2024, including “The High School Hero” and “Mashle: Magic and Muscles.”
- Upcoming Projects:Â Anime announcements and leaks suggest that they’re working on new seasons of established series like “DanMachi” (Is It Wrong to Try to Pick Up Girls in a Dungeon?) and “Food Wars! Shokugeki no Soma.”
Reasons Why J.C. Staff Might Deliver Good Animation:
- Experience with the Source Material:Â J.C. Staff already has experience animating One-Punch Man for season 2. This familiarity with the characters, world, and fighting style could lead to a smoother production for season 3.
- Potential for Improvement: Season 2 received criticism for its animation quality. J.C. Staff might be particularly motivated to redeem themselves and deliver a visually stunning season 3. The studio is also known for some of the most popular anime shows, you can read Top 5 JC Staff Anime that gives us the confidence that One Punch Man Season 3 will be great again to learn more.
- Understanding Fan Expectations:Â With the mixed reception of season 2, J.C. Staff is likely aware of fan expectations and could tailor their approach to better capture the series’ essence.
Reasons Why J.C. Staff Might Struggle:
- Workload Concerns:Â J.C. Staff is known for juggling multiple projects simultaneously. This heavy workload could lead to animation inconsistencies or delays in One-Punch Man season 3.
- JC Staff studio has been working on eleven different anime for 2024, this might add to the workload concerns and potentially make it the production procedure rushed if not given enough time.
Stay updated with all the latest news and exclusive insights by subscribing to our Spiel newsletter! Be the first to know about announcements from anime studios and get behind-the-scenes details on the making of the highly anticipated anime shows.
Is MAPPA Studio a better choice according to fans?
Fans hoped MAPPA would animate One-Punch Man, inspired by their stellar work on series like Jujutsu Kaisen and Attack on Titan. Though the rumours turned out false, they showed fans’ longing for top-notch animation to enhance the series.
Here are some reasons why some fans see MAPPA as a better choice for One-Punch Man season 3:
- Renowned Action Animation:Â MAPPA has garnered a reputation for producing high-quality action animation, evident in series like Jujutsu Kaisen and Attack on Titan. Fans believe this expertise could translate well to One-Punch Man’s explosive fight sequences.
- Experience with Popular Shonen Titles:Â MAPPA’s experience with popular shonen anime (series aimed at young male audiences) like Yuri!!! on Ice and The God of High School could be seen as an advantage in understanding the genre’s conventions and audience expectations.
- Consistent Visual Style:Â Although subjective, some fans might prefer MAPPA’s distinct visual style, known for its dynamic camera work and detailed character designs, believing it could elevate the series’ visual experience.
Some Arguments against MAPPA taking over the animation:
- Overworked Staff:Â MAPPA has faced criticism for their demanding work schedules and potential employee burnout. Fans might worry about the impact on both staff well-being and animation quality.
- Different Artistic Approach:Â MAPPA’s artistic style might not perfectly align with One-Punch Man’s unique blend of action and comedy. Some fans might prefer the series to retain its original visual identity.
- Focus on Existing Projects:Â MAPPA’s current workload includes several high-profile projects. Fans might be concerned that taking on One-Punch Man would further strain their resources and potentially impact the quality of all involved projects.
Conclusion
Season 1, known for its outstanding animation, was made by Madhouse. However, the switch to J.C. Staff for Season 2 led to a decline in quality. Fans want animation that matches the series’ thrilling fights and humor and season 3 of One-Punch Man could be a chance for redemption, but we’ll have to wait and see if it lives up to expectations.